How to read the citations: a bracketed name such as [Greenhouse] links to the source of the sentence before it. Words in quotation marks are the source’s own wording. Everything else is our summary. This page is general information, not legal advice.
What an ATS is, and what it is not
An applicant tracking system is the software an employer uses to post jobs, collect applications, store candidate records and move people through a hiring process. When you upload a resume, the system can turn it into a structured record. Workday, for example, describes resume parsing as the step that lets a recruiter create a prospect or job application from an attached resume. [Workday docs]
It is not a single judge that reads your resume and says yes or no. Vendors that add AI matching describe it as an aid to people. Greenhouse says its Talent Matching “does not automatically advance or reject candidates, and hiring decisions remain with recruiters and hiring managers.” [Greenhouse Talent Matching] Its product announcement says “the responsibility for reviewing and selecting applicants will always rest in the hands of the hiring team”. [Greenhouse, 2025]
Which systems are common? Jobscan’s August 2026 report says over 40% of Fortune 500 companies use Workday for talent acquisition and SuccessFactors has a 12% usage rate, and that it detected an ATS for 97.4% of Fortune 500 companies. It also says Taleo usage is decreasing among the Fortune 500. [Jobscan, 2026] Note the method: Jobscan “reverse-engineered the career pages for each company on the list”, so these figures describe what career sites run, not vendor contracts. [Jobscan, 2026]
What this means for you
How parsing works and what breaks it
Parsing means pulling text out of your file and placing it into fields: contact details, employers, titles, dates, education and skills. Vendors do not publish their full pipelines, so treat any confident diagram of numbered parsing steps as a simplification. What vendors do publish is what goes wrong. Workday says “Resume parsing results can vary based on resume format and order of words.” [Workday docs]
The most specific list any vendor publishes
Greenhouse’s help center lists the resume formatting issues that cause an unsuccessful parse. Quoted directly: [Greenhouse]
- “A resume with spaces between the letters.”
- “Resumes that include graphics, photos, or word art”
- “Resumes that are uploaded as an image, rather than a document (such as a .docx or .pdf)”
- “Complex resumes with tables, headers, and footers”
- “Resumes with the name and contact information in the header, footer, or text box”
- “Resumes that have a columned layout”
- “Resumes without clear sections and differing formats throughout each section”
- “Company names that don't include identifying words such as Inc., Co., LTD, or LLC.”
- “Resumes with incomplete job titles. For example, Sr. Account Exec instead of Senior Account Executive”
The same page adds a size limit: “Greenhouse Recruiting can't parse resumes larger than 2.5MB.” [Greenhouse]
Why columns are a problem
Textkernel, which makes resume-parsing software, puts column layouts at about 10 to 15 percent of CVs, and says without special handling “the system would mix bits and pieces of each column together”. It describes training a machine learning model to handle columns better. [Textkernel] So some parsers handle columns well and some do not, and you cannot tell which one an employer runs. A single column removes the risk.
Images and scans
Some parsers now read scans: Bullhorn says it upgraded its core parsing for all customers as of October 2026, and its updated parser supports image-based and scanned documents. [Bullhorn] Others warn against them. Greenhouse lists image uploads as a cause of failed parses, [Greenhouse] and Workday says “For best results, use resumes that don't have images or image-based styles.” [Workday docs]
Why you retype everything on Workday sites
Workday says it does not auto-fill fields an employer configures as hidden, and it lists Skills and Languages among the fields it does not auto-fill. Employers can also hide resume parsing for external candidates. [Workday docs] So having to retype can be the employer’s configuration, not a sign your resume failed. Check every auto-filled field before you submit.
A quick self-test (our heuristic, not a vendor tool)
File formats, per vendor documentation
Here is what each vendor’s own documentation lists. Employers can narrow these: Taleo, for instance, lets system administrators decide which formats are available. [Oracle Taleo, attachments]
| System | Formats the vendor lists | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Workday (Skills Match, which Workday plans to retire) | DOC, DOCX, HTM, HTML, PDF, RTF, TXT. An unsupported format cannot be scored. | [Workday Skills Match] |
| Oracle Taleo | Word (.doc and .docx), PDF, RTF, TXT, HTML, OpenOffice (.odt), WordPerfect (.wpd), among others; set per employer. | [Oracle Taleo, attachments] |
| Bullhorn | PDF, Word (.doc, .docx), RTF, plain text, HTML. | [Bullhorn] |
| Greenhouse | Treats .docx and .pdf as documents; an image upload, or a file over 2.5MB, fails to parse. | [Greenhouse] |
None of these vendors says a Word file is safer than a PDF with real, selectable text. The rule that holds everywhere: send a genuine document in the format the form requests.
Knockout questions: the documented automatic rejection
If you want to know where an automatic rejection really comes from, look at the questions on the application form, not the resume. Oracle’s Taleo documentation defines it plainly: “A disqualification question is a single-answer question that contains the minimum requirements for a candidate to be eligible for a job.” And: “Answers to the disqualification questions decide if candidates move forward in the selection process or are automatically disqualified.” [Oracle Taleo docs]
Taleo also sorts criteria into Required (“It's like the minimum requirement.”) and Asset (“It's like a strongly preferred or nice to have qualification.”), with optional numeric weights on answers. [Oracle Taleo docs]
Recruiters describe the same pattern. In interviews with 25 US recruiters published by Enhancv in 2025, 23 said their system does not auto-reject for formatting, content or design, a small minority had content-based thresholds configured, and knockout questions were used to screen for work authorization, certifications or location. Enhancv sells resume tools and the sample is small, so read it as recruiters’ accounts, not a measurement. [Enhancv]
What this means for you
How recruiters search and filter
Once your record is in the database, a recruiter finds it the way you would expect: by searching and filtering.
Keyword search
Oracle’s Taleo documentation says “Keyword search is considered to provide exact matches.” By default, words in the Keywords field are joined with AND, and Boolean operators and trailing wildcards are supported. An optional related-terms setting widens the search, and a separate Conceptual Search returns documents that “do not need to contain everything entered as search criteria, only related concepts.” [Oracle Taleo, keyword search] [Oracle Taleo, conceptual search]
Greenhouse describes “toggling keywords between “Preferred” (OR statements) and “Required” (AND statements)”, searching job titles, skills, locations and more in resumes and internal notes, and says “Greenhouse even generates suggested keywords from your public job post”. [Greenhouse keyword search]
The practical point is not a keyword count. It is that the posting’s own wording can be exactly what the recruiter searches for, and Greenhouse builds suggested keywords from it. If the posting asks for financial planning and analysis and you did that work, use those words, not only a synonym.
Filters
In Jobscan’s survey of 384 recruiters (February to March 2025), 76.4% said they filter by skills, 59.7% by education and 50.6% by certifications, and “Over 44% of recruiters we surveyed filter candidates by years of experience.” Jobscan sells resume tools; treat these as one vendor’s survey. [Jobscan recruiter survey]
Filters on dates exist in the tools themselves. Greenhouse announced it would release an “AI-enabled filter for years of experience and skills” in May 2025. [Greenhouse, May 2025] LinkedIn’s community team describes a Year of Graduation filter, under Advanced Search in LinkedIn Recruiter, as a way to narrow a talent pool to recent graduates. [LinkedIn]
Filters are set by people, and employers themselves say filters exclude qualified candidates. In a 2021 Harvard Business School and Accenture report, as summarized by HR Dive, “Of employers surveyed, 88% said that qualified, high-skilled candidates were rejected outright from the hiring process” because they did not exactly match the hiring criteria. That is what employers said, not a measured rejection rate. [HR Dive]
AI matching, as vendors document it
Vendors now offer features that grade or rank applicants against the job. Here is what four of them say, in their own documentation.
Workday Candidate Skills Match
Workday HiredScore grades
Greenhouse Talent Matching
iCIMS
What this means for you
Dates, age and the law
The facts in the previous sections add up to one point that matters to anyone over 40: your dates are data. A matching tool may read employment start and end dates, [Greenhouse Talent Matching] a filter can act on years of experience, [Greenhouse, May 2025] [Jobscan recruiter survey] and LinkedIn Recruiter can filter on graduation year. [LinkedIn] None of this shows that any particular employer screens by age. It does mean the dates you include are machine-readable.
What federal law says
“The Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) forbids age discrimination against people who are age 40 or older.” It applies to employers with 20 or more employees. [EEOC] The EEOC says a job advertisement may not show a preference based on age, and gives the example of an ad seeking “recent college graduates”, which may discourage people over 40 from applying and may violate the law. It also says pre-employment questions that may indicate an applicant’s age should generally be avoided. [EEOC, prohibited practices]
Asking your age or date of birth on an application is not, by itself, a violation of the ADEA. The federal regulation says such requests tend to deter older applicants, so they are closely scrutinized for a permissible purpose, and it defines “employment applications” to include résumés. [29 CFR 1625.5]
State law: Colorado as an example
Colorado’s Job Application Fairness Act says that “On and after July 1, 2024, an employer shall not request or require an individual to include the individual’s age,” “date of birth, or dates of attendance at or date of graduation from an educational institution” “on an initial employment application.” If an employer asks for transcripts or certifications at that stage, it must tell you that you may redact that information. [C.R.S. 8-2-131] Other states have their own rules; check the law where the job is.
When software has been the problem
In 2017 testimony to the EEOC, an AARP Foundation attorney said some online applications “require applicants to include dates of birth or graduation dates in fields that cannot be bypassed”, and some “use drop-down menus that only go back, say, to the 1980s”. That is advocacy testimony, not an EEOC finding. [AARP Foundation testimony, 2017]
In a lawsuit, the EEOC alleged that “iTutorGroup programmed their tutor application software to automatically reject female applicants aged 55 or older” and male applicants aged 60 or older. iTutorGroup agreed to pay $365,000 to settle the suit (September 2023). The EEOC’s release refers to “more than 200 qualified applicants” and to injunctions against “requesting applicants' birth dates”. [EEOC, 2023]
Mobley v. Workday: an allegation, not a finding
Derek Mobley alleges that Workday’s AI screening tools disadvantaged him and other older job seekers. On May 16, 2025, Judge Rita Lin of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California granted preliminary certification of a collective under the ADEA, covering applicants aged 40 and older who were denied employment recommendations through Workday’s platform since September 24, 2020. [Holland & Knight]
That was a preliminary step with a low bar, not a decision on the merits. Workday argued, among other things, that it does not offer employment recommendations. [Davis Wright Tremaine] On July 29, 2025, the court said the collective, at this preliminary stage, includes individuals whose applications were scored, sorted, ranked or screened using HiredScore AI features, which is the product behind the grades described above. [Court order, July 2025] By 2026 the parties were in discovery. [CDF Labor Law, 2026]
Status as reported by the cited sources; checked November 12, 2026. We found no ruling on the merits in those sources.
What this means for you
Myth vs. fact
The 75 percent figure deserves its own note. HiringThing, an ATS vendor, traced it to Preptel, a company that sold resume services and went out of business in August 2013, and found no study or survey behind it. [HiringThing]
| Myth | What the sources show |
|---|---|
| The widely repeated 75 percent ATS rejection rate. | No study supports it. The figure traces to Preptel, a resume-services company that closed in August 2013. [HiringThing] In 2025 interviews, 23 of 25 US recruiters said their system does not auto-reject for formatting, content or design. [Enhancv] |
| The ATS scores your resume and rejects everything below a cutoff. | Not as a rule. Greenhouse says its AI matching does not reject anyone, [Greenhouse Talent Matching] but employers can configure thresholds: 2 of 25 recruiters in a 2025 Enhancv study said theirs auto-rejects below one. [Enhancv] The clearest documented automatic rejection is the answer to a screening question. [Oracle Taleo docs] [Greenhouse auto-reject] |
| Older systems such as Taleo only match exact keywords. | Taleo keyword search is exact by default, but it also offers related terms and a conceptual search that does not require every term. [Oracle Taleo, keyword search] [Oracle Taleo, conceptual search] Exact matching is a search option the recruiter chooses, not a property of a vendor. |
| Taleo prefers .doc over .docx. | No source we found states such a preference. Taleo’s documentation lists both .doc and .docx as supported formats. [Oracle Taleo, attachments] |
| Newer AI-era systems read complex layouts fine. | Greenhouse’s own help center lists tables, headers, footers, text boxes and columns as causes of failed parses. [Greenhouse] |
| Repeat each keyword a set number of times, or aim for a target keyword count. | No vendor we checked documents density, frequency or counts. Documented matching is about required skills and qualifications. [Workday Skills Match] [Workday HiredScore] |
| White text with hidden keywords gets you past the system. | Unproven and risky. Hiring platforms report finding it, some prompts get through and are found later, and some recruiters reject the candidate when they find it. [New York Times] The largest study we found did not measure whether it changes outcomes. [arXiv, 2026] |
| An ATS cannot read PDFs. | Taleo and Bullhorn list PDF as a supported format, and Greenhouse treats a .pdf as a document. [Greenhouse] [Oracle Taleo, attachments] [Bullhorn] |
| You can never know which ATS an employer uses. | For the largest employers it can be identified: working only from career pages, Jobscan’s 2026 report detected an ATS for 97.4% of Fortune 500 companies. [Jobscan, 2026] |
A sourced checklist
Run through this before each application. Each item names its reason.
Use one column, with your name and contact details in the body of the page.
Greenhouse lists columned layouts, and contact information placed in a header, footer or text box, as causes of failed parses. [Greenhouse]
No tables, text boxes, graphics, photos or word art.
All are on Greenhouse’s list of parse-failure causes, and Workday recommends resumes without images or image-based styles. [Greenhouse] [Workday docs]
Submit a real document, never a scan or a photo of one.
Greenhouse lists image uploads as a failure cause, and Workday recommends resumes without images. [Greenhouse] [Workday docs]
Use plain section headings and keep each section formatted the same way.
Greenhouse lists resumes without clear sections, and with differing formats throughout each section, as a failure cause. [Greenhouse]
Write job titles out in full, and avoid letter-spaced text.
Greenhouse’s example: “Sr. Account Exec instead of Senior Account Executive”. It also lists “A resume with spaces between the letters.” [Greenhouse]
Send the format the form asks for, and keep the file small.
Vendors support both PDF and Word; Greenhouse cannot parse files larger than 2.5MB. [Oracle Taleo, attachments] [Greenhouse]
Read every screening question slowly and answer it accurately.
In Taleo, disqualification answers can remove you automatically. [Oracle Taleo docs]
Use the posting’s own words for skills and titles you genuinely have.
Taleo keyword search is exact by default, and Greenhouse suggests search keywords from the public job post. [Oracle Taleo, keyword search] [Greenhouse keyword search]
State each basic qualification in the posting explicitly, if you meet it.
HiredScore’s top grades require meeting all basic qualifications, and Taleo prescreening separates Required criteria from Assets. [Workday HiredScore] [Oracle Taleo docs]
Check every field after the form auto-fills from your resume, especially skills.
Workday says parsing results vary with format and word order, and it does not auto-fill Skills or Languages. [Workday docs]
Every date you give must be true. Decide which dates the resume needs.
Recruiting tools offer filters on years of experience and graduation year, and federal law forbids age discrimination against people 40 or older at employers with 20 or more employees. [Greenhouse, May 2025] [LinkedIn] [EEOC]
Never hide text in white or tiny fonts.
Hiring platforms report finding it, and some recruiters reject the candidate when they do. No study has shown it helps. [New York Times] [arXiv, 2026]
Third-party resume checkers, including ours, are not the employer’s system. They can point out problems a parser or a reader is likely to trip on. PassTheScan’s free check reads your resume and shows what it finds. Run the free check on your resume.
Frequently asked questions
Does an ATS automatically reject resumes?
It can, when the employer sets it up to. The clearest documented case is the screening question: in Oracle Taleo, answers to disqualification questions decide whether a candidate moves forward or is automatically disqualified, and Greenhouse lets employers auto-reject applicants who give a designated answer to a question. The AI matching features themselves are described as aids: Greenhouse states that its Talent Matching does not automatically advance or reject candidates. Some employers do set score thresholds, though: in Enhancv's 2025 interview study, 2 of 25 recruiters said their system auto-rejects below a content threshold.
Sources: [Oracle Taleo docs] [Greenhouse auto-reject] [Enhancv] [Greenhouse Talent Matching]
Is it true that 75% of resumes are rejected by an ATS before a human sees them?
No study supports that figure. HiringThing traced it to Preptel, a company that sold resume services and went out of business in August 2013, and found no study behind it. In interviews Enhancv published in 2025, 23 of 25 US recruiters said their system does not auto-reject for formatting, content or design.
Sources: [HiringThing] [Enhancv]
Should I send a PDF or a Word document?
Send what the application asks for. Oracle Taleo and Bullhorn list both PDF and Word formats as supported, as does Workday's documentation for its Candidate Skills Match feature, which Workday plans to retire, and Taleo administrators choose which formats their own site accepts. What vendors warn against is an image of a resume: Greenhouse lists a resume uploaded as an image, rather than a document such as a .docx or .pdf, as a cause of a failed parse. None of the vendor documents we checked says DOCX is safer than a text-based PDF.
Sources: [Workday Skills Match] [Oracle Taleo, attachments] [Bullhorn] [Greenhouse]
Do I need to repeat keywords a certain number of times?
No vendor we checked documents keyword counts, keyword density or a target number of keywords. What vendors do document is matching against the job: HiredScore grades depend on whether basic and preferred qualifications are met. Recruiters also run keyword searches, which in Taleo are exact by default, so use the posting's own terms once, where they are true.
Sources: [Workday HiredScore] [Oracle Taleo, keyword search]
Can an ATS see my age?
It stores the dates you give it. Greenhouse Talent Matching uses employment start and end dates and years of experience, Greenhouse announced an AI-enabled filter for years of experience in May 2025, and LinkedIn Recruiter has a Year of Graduation filter. The federal Age Discrimination in Employment Act forbids age discrimination against people 40 or older, and Colorado bars employers from requesting or requiring age, date of birth, or dates of attendance or graduation on an initial application. Never misstate a date; you can choose which dates a resume needs.
Sources: [Greenhouse Talent Matching] [Greenhouse, May 2025] [LinkedIn] [EEOC] [C.R.S. 8-2-131]
Does hiding keywords in white text work?
Nobody has measured whether it works, and it carries a real trust risk. According to a 2025 New York Times report, Greenhouse estimated that 1% of resumes it reviewed in the first half of the year contained a trick, and ManpowerGroup said it detects hidden text in roughly 10% of the resumes it scans with AI. The same report says some prompts get through and are found only afterward, and that some recruiters reject the candidate when they find one. A 2026 study of hidden prompts in resumes says it did not assess whether they change screening outcomes. We advise against it: a recruiter who finds it has a reason to doubt everything else on the page.
Sources: [New York Times] [arXiv, 2026]
Sources
Every source below was opened and checked against the sentence that cites it on November 12, 2026. Vendor documentation changes; the date shown is the one the source gives.
- Greenhouse Support. Unsuccessful resume parse. Last updated March 2, 2026.
- Workday Administrator Guide. Resume Parsing. Last updated June 23, 2023.
- Workday Administrator Guide. Candidate Skills Match (Workday says it plans to retire this feature). Last updated June 23, 2023.
- Workday HiredScore documentation. Candidate Grades. Last updated June 23, 2023.
- Greenhouse Support. Talent Matching Data Processing FAQ. Last updated February 2, 2026.
- Greenhouse newsroom. Greenhouse Real Talent launches to fix overwhelming candidate pipelines while combatting fraud and spam in hiring. June 3, 2025.
- Greenhouse newsroom. Greenhouse unveils new AI-driven products at UNLEASH to streamline hiring in saturated job market. May 7, 2025.
- Greenhouse. Talent Filtering keyword search (product page). Undated; read November 12, 2026.
- Bullhorn Knowledge Base. Resume Parsing in Bullhorn ATS. Undated; notes a parser upgrade for all customers as of October 2026.
- Textkernel blog. Improving extraction from column resumes. Undated; read November 12, 2026.
- Oracle Taleo Enterprise documentation. Prescreening Candidates. Release 21B; read November 12, 2026.
- Oracle Taleo Enterprise documentation. Attachment. Undated; read November 12, 2026.
- Oracle Taleo Enterprise documentation. Candidate Advanced Search with Keywords. Undated; read November 12, 2026.
- Oracle Taleo Enterprise documentation. Conceptual Search. Undated; read November 12, 2026.
- iCIMS. AI recruiting software (product page). Undated; read November 12, 2026.
- Jobscan. Applicant Tracking System (ATS) Usage Report, 6th edition (Fortune 500). August 20, 2026.
- Jobscan. State of the Job Search 2025. February 25, 2025.
- Enhancv. Does ATS reject resumes? (interviews with 25 US recruiters). Published November 3, 2025; updated November 11, 2026.
- HiringThing blog. Applicant tracking system myths. January 10, 2022.
- HR Dive. Report: Applicant tracking systems may exclude whole segments of candidates. September 15, 2021.
- The New York Times, reprinted by The Star. Recruiters use AI to scan resumes. Applicants are trying to trick it.. October 7, 2025 (reprint October 9, 2025).
- arXiv (preprint). Measuring Real-World Prompt Injection Attacks in LLM-based Resume Screening. May 27, 2026.
- U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. Age Discrimination. Undated; read November 12, 2026.
- U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. Prohibited Employment Policies/Practices. Undated; read November 12, 2026.
- Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute. 29 CFR 1625.5, Employment applications. Issued 1981; amended 1988 and 2007.
- Colorado Revised Statutes, via Colorado Public Law. C.R.S. 8-2-131, Job Application Fairness Act. Effective July 1, 2024.
- U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (meeting record). Written testimony of Laurie McCann, Senior Attorney, AARP Foundation Litigation, at the EEOC meeting on the ADEA at 50. June 14, 2017.
- U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (press release). iTutorGroup to pay $365,000 to settle EEOC discriminatory hiring suit. September 11, 2023.
- Holland & Knight. Federal court allows collective action lawsuit over alleged AI hiring bias. May 27, 2025.
- Davis Wright Tremaine. AI Screening Tools Under Scrutiny: Federal Court Preliminarily Certifies ADEA Collective Action. May 21, 2025.
- CDF Labor Law. AI hiring litigation: key lessons for employers. August 27, 2026.
- Greenhouse Support. Auto-reject. Last updated January 30, 2026.
- U.S. District Court, Northern District of California (via CourtListener). Mobley v. Workday, Inc., No. 23-cv-00770-RFL, Order re HiredScore Dispute (Dkt. No. 158). July 29, 2025.
- LinkedIn Talent Community. Searching for recent grads? Use the graduation year filter in Recruiter. June 11, 2024.